Objections to street cameras are silly, or hiding something

By CHRIS POWELL

Just days after street surveillance cameras in Manchester and New York State enabled the apprehension of the suspect in a serious stabbing assault in Manchester, the town’s Board of Directors voted 5 to 4 to get rid of the cameras anyway, heeding complaints that they violate privacy.


Less aggressive, more thorough immigration policy could work

Murphy’s political blood pressure; and Connecticut’s eternal senator

‘Public’ schools, secret evaluations; and Democratic billionaires are OK


It’s a controversy throughout Connecticut and the country but it’s silly. For the street cameras, many of them operated by surveillance equipment and programming maker Flock Safety, are probably the country’s least intrusive and most beneficial mechanisms of surveillance.

For the street cameras record only the vehicles driving by and their license plates. They don’t record who is driving or where drivers are going or coming from, and their data can be and ordinarily is soon deleted at the direction of state law or client policy if no criminal investigation pursues the data. The relatives of the many people who have been murdered, abducted, or injured in Connecticut over the years in crimes without convictions might wish that such cameras had been available and deployed then.

Meanwhile modern life is full of far more invasive mechanisms of surveillance that somehow fail to rile up the people who are so upset about street cameras.

People always say they would like more police officers on walking and cruiser beats. That is in-person surveillance.

Mobile phone and internet networks and internet sites track users, and mobile phone and internet site use data is often volunteered or subpoenaed for criminal investigations. Yes, people can choose not to use mobile telephones and the internet while they can’t opt out of being recorded by street cameras, but for most people opting out of mobile phones and the internet is prohibitively impractical.

Banks, credit card companies, and credit rating agencies compile and share data about nearly everyone — data far more intimate than anything recorded by street cameras. This data can be shared voluntarily with or subpoenaed by law enforcement authorities. Who wants to try opting out of money and credit?

People are tracked when they use wireless internet services and when they walk or drive past stores, offices, and homes that have security cameras — more data that can be volunteered or subpoenaed.

And then, of course, there is government, which compiles all sorts of personal data on nearly everyone — some of which is properly required by law to be public as a matter of government accountability and public safety.

The people opposing street cameras say they don’t trust camera system operators to follow the law about what surveillance data is to be disclosed and what data is to be deleted. Yes, there are violations with databanks, as government employees are sometimes caught improperly using access to government databases for personal spying.

But unlike other databanks, street camera system databanks have no intimate personal information to compromise; all they can say about people is that their vehicles drove by a certain place at a certain time. Unless that information is relevant to a criminal investigation, who cares?

The opponents of street cameras don’t trust Flock Safety but apparently do trust all the entities compiling intimate personal data not to disclose it improperly.

The opposition to street cameras is either paranoia or camouflage for another agenda that a few opponents of street cameras have let slip. That is, they say they don’t want street cameras used to help enforce federal immigration law, as street cameras could be used to locate people violating immigration law just as they are used to locate other lawbreakers.

This seems like the only objection to street cameras that makes much sense – the only objection that would make irrelevant the many institutionalized risks to privacy. Indeed, some use of street cameras in Connecticut and around the country already has been conditioned on forbidding release of the data to immigration enforcement authorities.

For with some of the opponents of street cameras, it may be better to let murderers, rapists, robbers, burglars, and other criminals escape than to apprehend even one illegal immigrant.


Chris Powell has written about Connecticut government and politics for many years. (CPowell@cox.net)

Leave a Reply